As a political scientist, I have been reminded this year, more than others, how economic policy is conflated with public policy.

We are often told what is best for business is best for the city/county/state/country. Because we hear this phrase so much, we often do not question the statement. Since we often do not question the statement, we do not scrutinize the information presented to support the statement, even if the reality is harming general public policy goals.

Because we do not question, we are often pressured at all levels of government to blindly accept estimates of data on the promise of jobs or sales taxes or economic development.

Perhaps it is easier to accept information from the presenter than it is to question information to ensure the business talk actually benefits the community/state/country.

Tammy R. Greer has a PhD in political science and teaches public policy. Credit: Courtesy photo

It appears that as it relates to all aspects of our society, the primary, secondary and tertiary goals are primarily focused on the wants and needs of business, regardless of the impact on the people of the community/state/country.

Often, elected officials and business tend to speak negatively about regulation. Officials and business leaders discuss the negative impact of regulation on business. Then claim regulations impact the cost of business which can delay goods and services to communities. This claim has been told and retold whether about foods, infrastructure, housing, and other components.

The challenge with the lack of regulations is visible in the challenges we had in our recent memory. 

Whether the food we eat is filled with bacteria and people become sick; once eradicated communicable diseases reemerged; airplanes being grounded or falling from the skies; cyber security challenges impacting critical infrastructure and people’s ability to simply be productive workers — regulations are designed for safety to reduce or avoid these items. Yet, business uses risk assessments to determine the level of risk the business is willing to accept over the safety and security of the people who use and consume the goods or services.

The risk assessment is not about the people as a whole. The risk assessment is concerned with how much money a company is willing to lose (including settling lawsuits) before being forced to do anything about the issue such as a reactive recall of products because the harm was greater than expected — the risk became financially unacceptable.

What changes though? Not much. There is a publicly issued acknowledgement of mistakes and promises of doing better. The company will donate money to a nonprofit in an effort to do image repair. Yet, does the process change? Will public policy change?

In the last five years or so, technology has moved quickly with new programming and devices. These new technologies then exploit the lack of public policy. We are encouraged to accept these new technologies without anyone pressing pause to understand the purpose, gaps and potential consequences for the sake of “not being behind” one country or another.

The “move fast and break it” approach seems like we moved from a mentality to reality.

Business has moved so fast, so many of our once safe systems are breaking because public policy has moved out of the way — opening the lane for the unfettered sprint to an end goal that we are unsure of what that accomplishment looks like 

One of the largest pushes against public policy is artificial intelligence. Public policy has not caught up with the speed of the industry. Workforce and universities are pushing artificial intelligence without guardrails, speed bumps and chokepoints to understand the impact on productivity, way of life and financial security.

The Peach Pulse

Become a founding subscriber

Get PeachPol’s exclusive Georgia political reporting and analysis — and lock in your founding subscriber rate as long as your subscription remains active.

Become a founding subscriber

These leaders tell us that while some jobs will be lost, others will be created. When asked specifically what jobs will be created, those same people are unsure because the new jobs are jobs we cannot imagine.  What does that mean? If the people who are taking employment away from communities, then say new jobs will be created yet cannot tell us what types of jobs they will be so that we can begin to train for those new jobs, then it seems like we are being gaslit.

The promise of new jobs or promise of economic development appears to be the reality public policy leaders need in order to say yes to intangible plans by the business community. Do these plans turn into reality? Are we asking about the long-term impact?

Public policy has not had time to fully explore the legal implications, civil-liberties concerns, environmental impacts, effects on education, critical-thinking skills and reading comprehension, cognitive development and socialization. Sure, public policy is slow. Honestly, public policy is usually slow to such matters — because public policy is thoughtful and deliberate about the people as a whole.

If we are just moving fast and breaking it — what is “it”? The “it” seems to be all the fabrics of society that we have made progress toward in the last century. It appears that business is driving public policy rather than public policy ensuring business drives us to an improved place.

Business is asking public policy to trust business. It is curious, has business earned our trust? Are we being distracted from the harms that are happening for the newest shiny device, or faster internet, or novel digital game. Are these items taking our attention away from our personal data, security, employment, clean water, clean air and clean soil?

Is being faster than other countries worth the long-term impact of our state and country? Are the people who are saying yes living with the impact of these consequences or are they telling us to live with the consequences while they are sheltered from the impact?

Being stagnate is not our reality. There is progress in business and technology. At the same time, are our public policy experts opening the door for the lack of supervision or moving out of the way so that anyone can do whatever, whenever? There is an appropriate balance between doing a “both/and.” 

Do we have a collective will to move more deliberately to ensure business moves in a manner that upholds the safety of the community/state/country — being that many businesses receive tax breaks and tax incentives to create and expand their organization?

Public policy is more than dollars and cents  Is this conflation between the role of business and the trust of public policy making sense?

Tammy R. Greer has a PhD in political science and teaches public policy.


Want sharper Georgia political analysis in your inbox? Become a founding subscriber to The Peach Pulse.